Harry Styles debuted an unreleased acoustic song, “What Is Enough”, during his 16 October concert at Madison Square Garden in New York. The performance came on the second anniversary of the death of his former One Direction bandmate Liam Payne. Deadline, Billboard and People separately reported the moment, drawing on concert footage and Styles’s introduction from the stage.

Before playing the song, Styles spoke about friends who had shaped his life and said the piece was written for a friend about two years earlier. He framed the performance around grief, gratitude and looking after one another. Styles did not announce a studio recording, release date or plans to add the song to a future project, so “What Is Enough” remains a live-only, unreleased work unless he says otherwise.

Styles and Payne became members of One Direction in 2010 alongside Niall Horan, Louis Tomlinson and Zayn Malik. The group entered an indefinite hiatus in 2016 after Malik’s earlier departure. Styles is now playing a 30-night Madison Square Garden residency as part of his “Together, Together” tour, supporting his fourth solo album, “Kiss All the Time. Disco, Occasionally.” The New York run is scheduled to continue through the end of October.

Reporting and records

Corrections or questions? Contact us.